Back to basics

‘Europe’s Unfinished Currency’ by Thomas Mayer underlines the seeds of the euro’s troubles and how it can survive

Europe’s Unfinished Currency: The Political Economics of the Euro, by Thomas Mayer, Anthem Press £19.99/$26.99, 272 pages

When the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, East Germans shouted in the streets: “If the D-Mark doesn’t come to us, we will come to it!”

Modern money, in other words, is highly political – a fact that is once again painfully apparent in Europe. For Thomas Mayer, a senior fellow at the Goethe University in Frankfurt and senior adviser to Deutsche Bank, the crisis now engulfing the eurozone can largely be explained by the single currency’s origins as a project to bring about greater unity. If its future is to be assured, Europe’s leaders will need to return to economic fundamentals.

For most of the euro’s first decade, Mayer argues in Europe’s Unfinished Currency, flaws in the European monetary union were papered over by cheap credit. But things were quietly going wrong. Citizens in Greece and Portugal borrowed heavily and lenders failed to take a rigorous approach to credit quality. Financial markets treated the government debt of all eurozone nations as risk-free, while the architects of the euro failed to plan for a crisis, destroying their credibility when disaster struck.

The irony, for Mayer, is that by the time the euro came into circulation, its rationale no longer made sense, the prospect of another catastrophic European war having disappeared with the fall of the Berlin Wall. Nor does he find much evidence of economic benefits. In particular, he believes that we cannot say with any certainty that Germany has reaped any clear rewards from membership.

Mayer disagrees with German chancellor Angela Merkel’s push to achieve greater fiscal and political union in Europe. He also makes a case for the European Central Bank to be allowed to lend directly to governments, something that Merkel has resisted strongly.

Instead, Mayer proposes a tougher, meaner eurozone: one in which governments have a real incentive to tidy up their finances. Europe, he argues, should model itself along the lines of the US in the mid-19th century, in which states were left to default on their debt and became more fiscally conservative as a result.

Europe’s Unfinished Currency can be read as a primer for the eurozone crisis, though lay readers may struggle with some of the economic debate. Terms such as seigniorage or book money are not always fully explained, and a chapter dedicated to the operations of balance of payments between eurozone countries and Target2 payments on the European Central Bank’s balance sheet is particularly dense.

Mayer’s rejection of political and fiscal union also raises the question of why he tries so hard to find a solution for the euro. The answer is that he is very concerned about the longer-term effects of central banks printing money. He thinks that “when” US central bankers lose control of inflation, there will be a loss of confidence in the global monetary system and the dollar. That could see smaller countries struggling to defend the value of their currencies. A Europe with a common currency, he believes, will survive in this world better.

Alice Ross is the FT’s currencies correspondent

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2016. All rights reserved. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from and redistribute by email or post to the web.

More on this topic

Suggestions below based on Thomas Mayer

A parallel currency for Greece?

Based on the latest opinion polls, the Greek election could result in a highly confused outcome, with the new government being unable or unwilling to meet any budgetary terms acceptable to the Troika, but also unwilling to leave the euro voluntarily. What would happen then?

Greek funny money, redux

First it was John Dizard arguing that Greece could issue scrip and have this circulate as “money” during a funding stand-off with the Troika — without getting chucked out of the eurozone.

The ECB and boosting the EFSF

The European Central Bank favours the eurozone using as flexibly as possible its €440bn bail-out fund, the European Financial Stability Facility. But does that include giving the EFSF access to its liquidity?

How to backstop the eurozone

What could provide the eurozone with an effective backstop and ensure its financial stability? The lack of a safety net is the main reason why investors remain so nervous about Europe’s monetary union. In the US and UK, the central banks are seen - rightly or wrongly - as offering the ultimate defence.

Bini Smaghi, Greece and fairytales

Lorenzo Bini Smaghi, European Central Bank executive board member, used an interview in today’s Financial Times to explain in detail just why the ECB is so opposed to any kind of Greek debt restructuring. In doing so, he took on directly those such as Nouriel Roubini and Deutsche Bank’s Thomas Mayer, who have called for an “orderly” restructuring, drawing on lessons learnt from the Latin American experience in the 1980s.