Passengers look at their smartphones while standing in a subway train in Beijing, China, on Tuesday, March 14, 2017. China has championed free trade and globalization, and while there have been issues with the process, the country is ready to work with other nations to improve the international governance system, Premier Li Keqiang said at a press conference in Beijing after the close of the annual National People's Congress on March 15. Photographer: Qilai Shen/Bloomberg
Passengers look at their smartphones on a subway train in Beijing © Bloomberg

Everyone in Beijing can now get on to public transport with the tap of a smartphone — everyone except Apple iPhone users.

Beijing’s public transport payments company Yikatong has launched an app that allows most Android smartphone users to pay for journeys by tapping their smartphone rather than their transport card, starting on Monday.

The upgrade fits well with the Chinese habit of using smartphones to pay for anything from utility bills to street food, and will serve as a template for transport systems across China. As such, the exclusion of iPhone is a blow for Apple.

The event shows just how badly the technology group is being beaten in mobile payments in China, the world’s largest with an estimated $8.8tn in transactions in 2016, according to iResearch.

Apple was locked out of the Beijing public transit payment system because of its policy of reserving contactless payment — that is, the ability to pay for something by waving a phone in front of a terminal — to its Apple Pay app, rather than granting access to to third-party apps such as Yikatong’s, or popular payment systems such as Tencent’s WeChat Pay and Alibaba’s Alipay.

Chart: Mobile transactions market in China

Android-based competitors such as Samsung, Huawei and Xiaomi do allow contactless payment that links to these apps.

“[Apple’s policy] is counterproductive,” said Mark Natkin, managing director of Marbridge Consulting, a Beijing-based tech consultancy. “It potentially locks them out of a variety of initiatives, particularly the major push in China to introduce smart city initiatives.”

WeChat Pay and Alipay are integrated into social messaging and ecommerce apps offered by Tencent and Alibaba, and are therefore extremely popular.

Moreover, Tencent and Alibaba’s payment systems involve scanning a QR code with a phone camera, rather than tapping something to make a payment. Chinese consumers are just more used to this system of code scanning, rather than Apple’s system of waving a phone in front of a cash register.

The upshot is that Apple, one of the first to offer contactless transactions in China, has been relegated to less than 1 per cent of China’s mobile payments market and is losing markets that embrace contactless payment.

“It’s very ironic that iPhones are excluded [from the Beijing public-transit upgrade] given that Apple Pay is one of the trailblazers for [contactless] payments in China,” said Matthew Brennan, co-founder of digital marketing agency China Channel.


Apple’s offering, which was launched in China in early 2016, has not made it into the top 10 payment apps in the country.

iPhone sales in Greater China fell during the past year while local competitors using the Android operating system stormed ahead.

Apple’s approach of guarding its contactless payment technology has not worked well in China, where Apple Pay occupies a small segment of the payments market and thus third-party app developers — such as Yikatong — can go ahead and develop alternative payment systems without co-operation from Apple.

“The vast majority of subway travellers are going to be using Android phones. It totally makes sense to prioritise those users,” added Mr Brennan.

* This article has been amended since original publication to correct the spelling of the name of Marbridge Consulting’s managing director, Mark Natkin

Get alerts on Apple Inc when a new story is published

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2019. All rights reserved.
Reuse this content (opens in new window)

Follow the topics in this article