Experimental feature

Listen to this article

Experimental feature

French supermarket operator Casino Guichard-Perrachon suffered the infamy of being hit with its second junk rating in a little over a year on Monday after Fitch Ratings became the latest to strip the company of its investment grade status.

Fitch cut its rating on Casino by a notch from BBB- to BB+, citing challenging conditions in the company’s French home market and the group’s high debt levels for the move. It kept its outlook on ‘stable’.

The downgrade reflects the weaker-than-expected profit growth in Casino’s core French market in 2016 relative to Fitch’s expectations.

We acknowledge Casino’s somehow lower presence in the challenged and low-margin hypermarket format relative to Carrefour, and its intention to focus efforts on the development of the higher-margin premium segments. However, EBITDA uplift is likely to be capped by weak demand and high competition. Since France represents 71% of proportionally consolidated EBITDA (2016, continuing activities), there is limited scope to improve group’s proportionally consolidated metrics.

The downgrade comes just 13 months after S&P downgraded France’s second-largest supermarket operator into speculative territory.

The comments on the difficult French market are also a timely reminder of the challenge that the winner of the French presidential election run-off will face in reviving France’s moribund economy.

Casino, which also has extensive operations in Brazil, has been under fire from Muddy Waters, the US short-seller, which last year described the company as “one of the most overvalued and misunderstood companies we have ever come across”.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2018. All rights reserved.

Comments have not been enabled for this article.