Sir Ronald Cohen wants to raise $1bn to support 150 education projects
Experimental feature

Listen to this article

00:00
00:00
Experimental feature

If there has been a gradual growth in social impact bonds over the past few years, Sir Ronald Cohen plans to sharply accelerate the trend in the months ahead.

The venture capitalist is seeking to raise $1bn by next summer to support education projects across Africa and the Middle East with payouts linked to outcomes, and a similar amount for India by the end of 2019, he said in an interview.

He hopes to raise funding from a mixture of governments, philanthropists and companies, which will provide money to underwrite some 150 projects backed by bonds to improve educational outcomes at different ages across a dozen of countries.

“If you want to bring systemic change to education, there has to be a more powerful way than lobbying for more money,” he says.

Social impact bonds, first pioneered by the UK in 2010 to help prevent reoffending among former prisoners, are structures through which private investors fund innovative approaches to social issues. They are reimbursed — usually by governments — only if they meet agreed targets.

The Brookings Institution in Washington DC has tracked their growth and provided the data in the table: over one hundred have been established since the start of the decade. The largest number are still focused in the UK, and most target social welfare and employment.

Yet they are increasingly being applied internationally — from the US to Uganda — for a wider range of projects and with backers including philanthropists and governments. While data are not always available, Brookings estimate social impact bonds have raised more than $364m since 2010.

For Sir Ronald, social impact bonds provide a way to generate greater funding for social policy while also proving attracting to investors. Notably, he argues they are a form of risk diversification because, “they deliver an uncorrelated return not linked to stock markets”.

Not everyone is so convinced. Michael Roy, a senior lecturer in social business at Glasgow Caledonian University, argues the bonds can be complex and costly to establish and monitor, imposing a heavy or impossible burden on many non-profit organisations.

As he and colleagues argued in the Stanford Social Innovation Review, the bonds shift social policy from a focus on citizens to the generation of return on investment. He concluded: “SIBs are both an archetypal “solution looking for a problem,” and an illustration of the cultural supremacy of market principles into all aspects of everyday life, including politics and policy.”

For those like Sir Ronald, at least in the absence of greater public funding, they provide a way to stimulate innovation, generating new money to launch closely-monitored projects in fields that have received insufficient investment up till now.


20 top social impact bonds
SIB NameCountrySectorUpfront Capital Commitment*
DC Water EIBUnited StatesEnvironment$25m
South Carolina Nurse-Family Partnership Pay for Success ProjectUnited StatesSocial Welfare$17m
Child-Parent Center Pay for Success InitiativeUnited StatesEducation$16.9m
NYC ABLE Project for Incarcerated YouthUnited StatesCriminal Justice$16.8m
Juvenile Justice Pay for Success InitiativeUnited StatesCriminal Justice$16.11m
Increasing Employment and Improving Public SafetyUnited StatesCriminal Justice$14.82m
Workplace Rotterdam SouthNetherlandsEmployment$14.58m
Integration and fast employment of immigrantsFinlandEmployment$14.2m
Adult Basic Education Pay for Success InitiativeUnited StatesEmployment$12.43m
Family StabilityUnited StatesSocial Welfare$11.2m
Just in ReachUnited StatesSocial Welfare$10m
Benevolent Society Social Benefit Bond (SBB)AustraliaSocial Welfare$9.32m
Denver Social Impact Bond ProgramUnited StatesSocial Welfare$8.6m
ONE ServiceUnited KingdomCriminal Justice$7.61m
Utah High Quality Preschool ProgramUnited StatesEducation$7m
ASPIREAustraliaSocial Welfare$6.86m
Project Welcome HomeUnited StatesSocial Welfare$6.8m
Newpin Social Benefit Bond (SBB) (SF Calls it UnitingCare Burnside)AustraliaSocial Welfare$6.73m
Youth Choices Social Benefit BondAustraliaCriminal Justice$6.42m
Type II DiabetesIsraelHealth$5.5m

Notes

* Conversion rate at contract signing unless dollar figure provided.
1. Database is missing investment data for 25/113 deals.
2. Dollar conversion is based on the date we have in the database for the start of the contract, unless provided in fact sheet.
Source: Brookings Institution Global Impact Bond Database, July 12 2018

Get alerts on Social and environmental impact investment when a new story is published

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2018. All rights reserved.
About this Special Report

Transformational Business

The global action community for impact investors wants China’s elite to start investing for good social and environmental outcomes, accountants are the new activists on the green scene, Investment products that promote gender equality are becoming more popular, and we list the top 20 global social impact bonds.

Follow the topics in this article