UK bank regulation: back to the future

Things will not change as much as Sir Mervyn King may hope

Back to the future. As the Bank of England prepares to take back regulatory oversight of banks in the UK at the end of next year, bank supervision will change. But not as much as Sir Mervyn King, governor, may hope. He wants to cut the mass of data required from banks so that policymakers and supervisors can see the wood for the trees, the better to spot systemic risks. The BoE will also have far greater powers for top-down regulation. But Sir Mervyn cannot hope to wield his supervisory baseball bat effectively unless he has decent data.

Sure, the tripartite regulatory system failed UK taxpayers. For all the previous government’s love of more regulation and more reporting, the box-ticking did not make the banking system safer. In the words of George Osborne, chancellor, the tripartite’s failure was not “a series of unfortunate accidents – it was hard-wired into its design.” Responsibility for monitoring systemic financial risks and changing financial institutions’ behaviour was split.

But supervisors from the BoE’s new Prudential Regulation Authority will need as much data as ever from banks if they are to do their job properly. It is how that information is used and the regulatory culture that must change. When tomorrow’s supervisor calls on banks’ senior executives, armed with intelligence from the BoE’s new, financial bubble and systemic pitfall-detecting Financial Policy Committee, he should be better able to zoom in on the two or three key risks that could bring down the bank. Or so goes the theory.

The proposed new regulatory framework under the BoE’s aegis looks broadly sensible. But whatever Sir Mervyn’s determination to cut red tape and costs by doing things differently, looming Basel III reforms and European Union variations on them could still derail his plan. Time to start investing in more computers, then.

E-mail the Lex team in confidence at lex@ft.com

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2017. All rights reserved. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.