Haydn/Gardiner, Barbican, London

Listen to this article

00:00
00:00

In the winter of his life Haydn understood why the seasons were such a concise metaphor for the human experience: “The blooms of your brief Spring are over/The power of your Summer is exhausted/Your Autumn soon fades into old age/Then comes the pallid Winter/pointing to an open grave.”

But what is so uplifting about Haydn’s portrait is that there is never a hint of bitterness. His seasons express an uncynical love of life and are firmly rooted in the soil – soil fertilised not just by sun but by “noble toil”.

It’s something that Haydn knew a lot about – as does John Eliot Gardiner, who conducted the English Baroque Soloists and Monteverdi Choir in this superlative performance. Initially it seemed a crazy way to spend a sunny Sunday afternoon, sitting in the concrete bunker of a metropolitan concert hall, but as The Seasons unfolded, I had no desire to be anywhere else. Haydn’s oratorio is a rarity, and it’s even rarer to hear it interpreted with such natural energy and lack of flab.

The Seasons is about nature’s beneficence and man’s unpompous place in it; about the joy of the harvest, the hunt and wine-making; about barking bassoons, mooing trombones, buzzing violins and the hymn-like harmony of human voices. The thunderstorm Beethoven was to conjure out of the Pastoral Symphony is already there; so are the forest murmurs of Weber’s Der Freischütz, without the dark overtones.

In short, despite winter’s “ill-humoured days”, The Seasons is an idealised portrait of life. The relationships it depicts are innocent. Unlike Mozart some years earlier, Haydn’s world-view still embraces the ancien régime: there’s no other way to explain his meek acceptance of a Christian finale, so tangential to all that has preceded it.

I enjoyed Dietrich Henschel’s Evangelist-like narration, singing off the words; James Gilchrist’s Lucas and Rebecca Evans’s Hannah were less inclined to interpret. But the key lay in Gardiner’s expressive command, irradiating Haydn’s positivity.
Tel 020 7638 8891

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2017. All rights reserved. You may share using our article tools. Please don't copy articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.