Elegy for love

A professor in his 40s writes a book-length love letter to the woman he has lost in Hillel Halkin’s ‘Melisande! What Are Dreams?’

Melisande! What Are Dreams?, by Hillel Halkin, Granta, RRP£14.99, 224 pages

Hillel Halkin’s deeply affecting love story begins with the sort of adolescent love triangle so beloved of Julian Barnes.

In 1950s New York, three students work together on their high school literary magazine. Hoo will one day become a professor of classical literature. His friend Ricky idolises Dostoevsky and is drawn to a wayfarer’s life, free of all possessions. Completing the trio is the beautiful Melisande, a compass trapped between two magnets.

Years later, Hoo, now in his 40s, writes to Melisande. His book-length love letter is also an elegy for the woman he has lost and for youthful dreams tempered by experience.

This is a strange fictional debut for a writer who has made his reputation as a commentator on Middle Eastern affairs in magazines such as The New Republic.

But the writing is pitch perfect – filled with quiet wisdom, and laced with nostalgia yet never cloying. The idiosyncratic title, in case you’re wondering, is a quote from Heine.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2016. All rights reserved. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.

More on this topic

Suggestions below based on Fiction

To be Frank

A Jewish salesman finds the famous diarist Anne Frank in his attic in Shalom Auslander’s comic but caustic tale ‘Hope: A Tragedy’

Pride and properness

Romesh Gunesekera’s ‘The Prisoner of Paradise’ is an east-west romance set in the fecundity of 19th-century Mauritius under British control

Totalitarian tales

Adam Johnson’s ‘The Orphan Master’s Son’ is a complex, multi-voiced narrative chronicling the horrific absurdities of life in North Korea

Eviction notice

A nuanced and darkly comic tale that probes a small community’s ethics to illuminate wider conflicts of aspiration, dignity and circumstance

Oh, Vienna

‘Waiting for Sunrise’, William Boyd’s assured psycho-sexual tale, segues from Kafka to Le Carré and reads almost like a homage