Fear of running out of battery has not held back the smartphone market. But it has crippled electric cars.
Now, however, some carmakers are increasingly confident that their electric vehicles are close to overcoming the dreaded “range anxiety”.
“Batteries are moving forward very, very quickly,” says Vincent Carré, electric car sales and marketing director for Renault, whose electric models include the Zoe compact vehicle, which has a range of about 120 miles.
“All of what you call range anxiety . . . is already behind us because we know that within a few years we will double the range of the cars, and after [that] we will again add 30 or 40 per cent [more range] before 2020.”
This implies an average Renault range of more 200 miles — the point at which it is generally accepted that electric vehicles become a viable mass market proposition.
Analysts say talk of range anxiety being overcome is premature, and highlight how the high cost of batteries is holding back electric cars as niche products. But some carmakers are optimistic these vehicles — one possible means of cutting the world’s greenhouse gas emissions — have finally moved beyond the stage of being confined to early technology adopters.
“Behind the scenes a fair amount of progress is getting made on these technologies,” says Dan Ammann, president of General Motors, which is working on a 200-mile, electric car called the Bolt that will cost $30,000 after incentives such as discounts or tax breaks. It is due to launch in 2017.
“More than 200-mile range, $30,000 is [a] really easy thing to explain to people,” he says. “This whole range anxiety . . . all of a sudden now it’s, well, this is accessible and does exactly what I need it to do.”
In Europe at least, sales of electric cars are starting to make some progress, albeit alongside alternative technologies that are also billed as environmentally-friendly.
Electric, hybrid and hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles are expected to register a 30 per cent increase in European sales in 2015 to 360,000 units, according to LMC Automotive, a forecaster.
In truth, this demand is coming off a low base — 360,000 equates to 2.5 per cent of all European car sales. And some will be because of the growing popularity of plug-in hybrids, which have electric motors supported by petrol engines to alleviate range anxiety.
The Europe-wide figures also mask wild variations. In Norway, for instance, electric vehicles and plug-in hybrids accounted for a third of all car sales in the first quarter of 2015, according to IHS Automotive. That’s because of high import tariffs on petrol vehicles.
In Germany, by contrast, just 25,000 electric vehicles have hit the autobahn so far, despite the government’s target of 1m plug-in sales by 2020.
As much as consumers have been reluctant to adopt electric vehicles, which are still well below 1 per cent of overall sales in most developed economies, some carmakers have been equally sheepish about throwing their weight behind the technology.
Electric and hybrid cars help manufacturers offset the impact of heavy sport utility vehicles, as they seek to meet strict fuel economy targets from regulators that are based on their overall automobile ranges.
But high battery costs mean few companies make money from electric cars.
“Honestly, we are struggling a little bit with the business model,” says Olivier François, head of the Fiat brand, which produces an electric version of its 500 compact car that is only sold in California.
Sergio Marchionne, chief executive of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, last year urged customers not to buy the 500e because the group lost $14,000 on each sale.
Manufacturers closely guard the exact pricing of their batteries. To reduce costs, Tesla, the innovative Californian electric carmaker, is constructing a battery factory in Nevada as part of plans to build a mass market vehicle called the Model 3.
Once at capacity in 2020, this plant will churn out more lithium-ion batteries than the combined global production today.
Cosmin Laslau, analyst at Lux Research, says many carmakers’ battery purchases have been done at prices well above the level he thinks is necessary for mass market adoption of electric cars.
In 2012, he estimates Ford was paying for its batteries as much as $650 per kilowatt hour — a measure of capacity. The bigger the capacity, the better the potential range of the car.
BYD, a Chinese carmaker, is aiming to reach $211 per kWh on battery costs — but only in 2025, says Mr Laslau. Tesla, by then, should be at $172/kWh, far ahead of any mass market rival.
“By crossing firmly below $200/kWh at the [battery] pack level, plug-in vehicles will become a mainstream subset of the overall automotive market,” says Mr Laslau.
Get alerts on Nevada when a new story is published