Global warming

Slim odds for a Copenhagen accord

A Martian visiting this week’s United Nations conference on global warming might conclude that there is no other issue with so much international consensus and momentum. There must be hope for humanity yet. But the inconvenient truth is that the odds of a binding treaty when leaders reconvene in 10 weeks in Copenhagen are slim.

The bogeyman of Kyoto, George W. Bush, may have been replaced by a passionate, internationalist Barack Obama and a Democratic Congress, but the US delegation is unlikely to have a specific pledge when it arrives in Denmark.

Healthcare and financial system reform are centre-stage, while a climate bill passed by the House languishes. Even that plan, for a 17 per cent reduction in emissions from 2005 levels by 2020, falls short of European and Japanese pledges.

The Senate ratifies treaties and its main objection to Kyoto was the exemption granted to developing nations, which is why President Hu Jintao’s bold language at this week’s summit inspired hope.

China has since claimed the top spot in carbon emissions and its participation, with perhaps a slight nod to its lower per capita output, is critical. The same is true for smaller developing nations which, as a group, have requested an unrealistic $400bn compensation from rich countries for binding limits.

With any other issue, the answer might be to aim for more modest goals or a limited agreement between the largest players. But the prospect of economic free riders poaching jobs and factories from signatories, and the fact that even a 70 per cent cut in emissions would merely stabilise atmospheric CO2 by the end of the century, make a grand deal necessary. Barring big, specific pledges by the US and China, their leaders’ oratory this week has been just more hot air.

E-mail the Lex team confidentially


Post public comments

The Lex column is on Twitter

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2016. All rights reserved. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from and redistribute by email or post to the web.

More on this topic

Suggestions below based on Lex

Gore urges US Senate to pass climate bill

A US Senate vote is ”the crucial step” in fighting climate change, Al Gore, former US vice-president, told the Clinton Global Initiative meeting in New York on Wednesday.

Obama strives for a nuclear bargain

Barack Obama will on Thursday become the first US president to chair a session of the United Nations Security Council. That, in itself, is a moment to celebrate, an event that testifies to his administration’s respect for the UN and its determination to act multilaterally. But Mr Obama’s presence at the Security Council will be more than symbolic. For the subject he has chosen for debate – the need to secure global agreement to stop the proliferation of nuclear weapons – is more than ever an issue of significance.