© The Financial Times Ltd 2014 FT and 'Financial Times' are trademarks of The Financial Times Ltd.
August 10, 2014 6:39 pm
Most people in business have a story about how China has changed their industry, how over the past 30 years it has upended supply chains and grabbed daunting market share. But very few have the sort of China story that John Bassett III has.
One day in November 2002, Mr Bassett, a third-generation furniture maker from Virginia, found himself in China meeting the Communist party official and businessman intent on putting him out of business.
This man’s ambitions and instructions were clear and direct: his company would soon be the biggest furniture manufacturer in the world and resistance was futile. Mr Bassett should shut his US factories and contract his production to China. It was the only way his business would survive.
“He was not belligerent, but it was just like you were speaking to a judge,” Mr Bassett tells Beth Macy in Factory Man, the new book that recounts his struggle to save his business and take on China. “He was absolutely serious and confident in what he was saying.”
Mr Bassett’s reaction was to do the very opposite. Within a year he had mobilised much of the US furniture industry and hired a top lawyer to mount a trade case against Chinese manufacturers for dumping bedroom furniture suites below cost on the US market. And if his furniture business is alive today it is largely because Mr Bassett won his fight.
We have for some time been awash in books detailing the costs in shut factories and lost jobs that has come with rise of China and the advent of truly international supply chains. But Factory Man deserves to be read for anyone wanting to wrap their heads around the present-day dynamics and politics of globalisation. Macy’s book is an important read, whether or not you agree with its premise and economics.
There is an element of Don Quixote about it, as some of Mr Bassett’s critics point out. Factory Man tells the story of one man’s fight to save a dying industry and the small southern towns that depend on it.
But it is also about the much bigger theme of US competitiveness and the angst over lost manufacturing jobs that has been at the heart of the debate over trade ever since Bill Clinton signed the North American Free Trade Agreement in 1993.
The figures are stunning. In the two years after China joined the World Trade Organisation in 2001 and cheap Chinese-made furniture began flooding the US market, almost a million jobs were lost as American furniture factories were shuttered, many of them in the rural Virginia and North Carolina company towns that over the previous century had become the focus of the industry in North America.
In truth, as Macy acknowledges, China did to those southern towns what they had done to Grand Rapids, Michigan just a few decades before, by paying lower wages and shamelessly turning out cheaper copies of popular furniture to grab market share.
The US industry also had its fair share of problems and misplaced arrogance. Among them was a boozy and sexually-charged business culture that leads Macy to describe its heyday as “Mad Men in the mountains. With moonshine instead of martinis”.
But the book nevertheless does a good job of showing how some successful US businesses have learnt to adapt and compete with China and started to “reshore” their production. Mr Bassett relentlessly invests in new machinery for his factories and decides that he will beat his Chinese competitors on quality and service rather than just price. The answer to China is not just to hire lawyers, the message goes, but to innovate.
It is also clear that there is an element of futility in fighting globalisation. After punitive anti-dumping duties are levied by the US the production of bedroom furniture does not come home to Virginia as Mr Bassett hopes, it moves to Vietnam. And the fight is costly: one economist estimates that the legal battle ends up costing $800,000 per job saved.
Yet Mr Bassett remains a compelling character with a compelling case.
Near the end of the book, his anti-dumping fight won and retirement nearing at age 75, he offers a typically plain-spoken account of why it is important to preserve a US manufacturing industry.
“Everybody thinks all the great ideas come outta MIT, but let me tell you, there’s a great deal of innovation that comes off the factory floor,” he tells Macy. “If we close everything that innovation’s gonna move to wherever the factory is. We gotta invest in America instead of derivatives.”
That is the sort of argument that plenty of Americans find appealing these days.
Factory Man: How One Furniture Maker Battled Offshoring, Stayed Local – And Helped Save an American Town, by Beth Macy, Little Brown and Company, RRP$28/£17
The writer is world trade editor
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2014. You may share using our article tools.
Please don't cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.