Financial Times FT.com

Dear Economist

Published: October 6 2006 19:44 | Last updated: October 6 2006 19:44

Dear Economist,

I’m an ambitious woman in my mid-twenties, just starting what I hope will be a stellar career in business. But I also very much want to have at least one child. How long should I leave it?

Yours sincerely,

Ms E. Jones, West London

..........................................................................................................................................

Dear Ms Jones,

Mothers seem to do worse in the labour market than women without children, but that might not be simple cause and effect. For instance, it might indicate that women who expected successful careers delayed having children, but the delay was not the cause of the success.

It all seems imponderable, but it isn’t. Amalia Miller, an economist at the University of Virginia, studied the timing of maternity and its effect on earnings. That effect is large: delay maternity by just one year and you can expect your career earnings to rise by 10 per cent, partly because you will work longer hours and partly because you will enjoy a better wage rate. For professionals like you, the wage effect is even higher.

These numbers strip out the effects of choice, because they are all based on accidents. Professor Miller made three types of comparison. She compared women who became mothers at 27 with those who became mothers at 28 despite both groups using contraception and therefore not choosing the timing. She also compared women who successfully got pregnant at 27 with women who tried at 27 but did not succeed for a year; or women who miscarried at 27 and then got pregnant again a year later. The women wanted the same date of pregnancy but bad luck intervened - and their careers benefited.

Professor Miller’s results suggest that you should leave your pregnancy as late as you dare. Her methods remind you, though, that you may not get to decide.

Questions to economist@ft.com

More from this columnist

Perhaps microfinance isn’t such a big deal after all

Dear Economist: Did Thierry’s head inform his hand?

Political ill wind blows a hole in the climate change debate

Dear Economist: Should I stay single in Italy – or come home?

Dear Economist: I love Walmart: my wife hates it. Help!

It’s not just Scrooge who wants Christmas abolished

Dear Economist: How can I be fair to my grandchildren?

Given the choice, how much choice would you like?

Dear Economist: Why a ‘pointless’ tax cut really counted

How a celebrity chef turned into a social scientist

Why feedback can be just so much noise

Left column content

Tim Harford

Undercover Economist

Tim Harford

Economics blog: Tim Harford writes ”The Undercover Economist”, about economics in everyday life, and ”Dear Economist”, in which readers’ questions are answered, tongue-in-cheek, with the latest economic theory

Join the discussion

Share your views on this column with Tim Harford and other FT readers

Market-moving economics

FT.com RSS Feeds

FT Lexicon