Financial Times FT.com

The Others

Review by Neel Mukherjee

Published: November 16 2009 07:22 | Last updated: November 16 2009 07:22

Book cover of 'The Others' by Siba al-HarezThe Others
By Siba al-Harez
Telegram Books £10.99, 310 pages
FT Bookshop price: £8.99

Siba al-Harez is a nom de plume. Given the subject of this debut novel, this is no bad thing. Even the name of the translator “is not listed at the translator’s request” (as the copyright page announces). The Others is Saudi Arabia’s, perhaps even the Gulf countries’, first lesbian novel: published in Beirut in 2006, it swiftly became a bestseller. The identity of the author remains shrouded; all we are allowed to know is that she is a 26-year-old Saudi woman from Al Qatif.

Al Qatif, on the eastern coast of the country, seems remote but the knowledge that this is a predominantly Shi’ite region brings a different kind of particularity to bear on the remoteness: the Shi’ites are an oppressed and heavily monitored minority group in the country. While this remains unarticulated in the novel, it can only magnify the isolation that comes with the narrator’s knowledge of her sexual otherness in a country not known for its liberal attitudes.

The unnamed 16-year-old narrator gives a raw and immediate account of her relationship with a glamorous, possessive, intense peer, named Dai, in a girls’ school. In his new book, Inside the Kingdom, Robert Lacey writes of how it is common for Saudi women, sealed off hermetically from any kind of male contact, to form lesbian attachments. The Others opens a door into one of the darkest and least-known corners of this society and the view is revelatory, sometimes shocking, always compelling. Who knew of the existence of a thriving online community indulging in homoerotic chats and interactions at night? Or of underground lesbian parties and trysts in hotels, all conducted with utmost secrecy?

Despite the intricately metaphorical language of the book, and its dense, flammable subjectivity, one of the most conspicuous markers of the narratorial voice is the all-consuming sense of guilt, shame and fear. Inseparable from the erotic longing and intimacy that are at the heart of the book, it makes for a unique, not wholly pleasant reading experience.

Neel Mukherjee’s debut novel, ‘A Life Apart’, will be published in January by Constable

More in this section

The Pregnant Widow

The Long Song

Diamond Star Halo

The Hopeless Life of Charlie Summers

Little Hands Clapping

The Lieutenant

Parrot and Olivier in America

The Privileges

The Swan Thieves

Even the Dogs

Beside the Sea

Jobs and classifieds

Jobs

Search
Type your search criteria below:

Investment Programme Manager

Transport for London

Communications Manager

Findus Group

Recruiters

FT.com can deliver talented individuals across all industries around the world

Post a job now