© The Financial Times Ltd 2013 FT and 'Financial Times' are trademarks of The Financial Times Ltd.
January 4, 2013 5:44 pm
The colours of a bullfight as the sun finally goes down. It’s not complicated. The elements of this photograph are controlled with a curious mix of indulgent austerity, and it remains seductive long after the clothes it was made to sell have passed into the archive.
The picture comes from early in the series of clothing catalogues Nick Knight made for Yohji Yamamoto and is dated 1986. The model was Sarah Wingate and Knight was an outsider. He’d made a documentary series about skinheads (the disaffected rightwing youth movement that was both scary and deeply fashion-conscious) and a series of exaggerated portraits of a new London in-crowd of the early 1980s in a commission for i-D magazine. Still not 30 when the Yamamoto commission came his way, his collaborations with graphic designer Peter Saville and art director Marc Ascoli were relatively new.
The catalogues were an experiment in how these confident, even arrogant, talents could work together, and they were a departure for the client too. It is always a wrench for a fashion house to publish pictures that give no very clear idea of the garments.
These pictures were a reaction against a period when fashion had been for a while even more overtly all about sex than usual. They are deliberately non-sexy in the same way that a Mohican and a pair of Doc Martens had been a few years before. They have technical brio. Knight hovers between flat representation and three dimensions: almost all of the girl, her cap, her long coat, her shoes are in inky black silhouette. It could have been drawn with a Rotring.
The bustle that flares out behind her is glittery translucent pink net, and every pleat catches its full complement of zinging highlights and dark shadows. The pool of shadow on the floor reminds us that this is a person, not just a graphic.
The little highlight on the heel is important: that’s where the flat blankness finally begins to curve into relief, and it’s the only place that shares something of the rival qualities of a map (on the left) and a sculpture (on the right). There is originality here but there are debts too, most obviously to Erwin Blumenfeld, the great innovator. It’s a cultured picture as well as a brash one.
Later in the same series of catalogues, Knight made a set of four pictures of Naomi Campbell in a red coat, the shapes as full as the sails of a J-Class yacht. Those are perhaps better known than this one but in the red coat photographs, Knight made a formal error that jars badly: he cut the girl off at the ankles and, in one version, at the top of the head too. This is better. There is no slippage here. This is a collision of punky daring with a very British puritanism.
This is part of a series on photography appearing in the FT and in FT Weekend. To see more selections, go to www.ft.com/hodgson
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2013. You may share using our article tools.
Please don't cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.