Financial Times FT.com

Lehman Brothers

SEC poised to act on short-selling

By Joanna Chung in New York

Published: September 15 2008 15:54 | Last updated: September 15 2008 21:10

US securities regulators are expected to adopt new measures against abusive short-selling as early as this week in response to financial market turmoil, according to people briefed on the situation.

Short-sellers aim to profit from share declines, usually by borrowing a stock, selling it and buying it back after its price has decreased. In ”naked” short-selling, shares are sold without being borrowed first.

The practice has become increasingly controversial, not least because many companies, including investment bank Lehman Brothers – which filed for bankruptcy on Monday – had claimed that short-sellers were engaging in campaigns to drive down their share prices.

The Securities and Exchange Commission, which planned to enact two new measures at the end of the month, is now under growing pressure to act sooner.

It was unclear what impact, if any, naked short-selling had on the acceleration of the fall in Lehman’s share price in the past week. But the latest market developments “should move the SEC to do more about naked short-sellers,” said John Coffee, professor of law at Columbia University.

However, the new rules, if approved by the SEC, would differ from the emergency measure which had protected a select group of financial shares, including Lehman’s, until it expired last month. The emergency measure had required traders to borrow the security first and deliver at settlement.

Under the new rules, brokers would have to deliver shares that have been sold short and it would be illegal for short sellers to deceive brokers about their intention to deliver shares.

They may also eliminate an exemption that options market-makers had from delivering shares of companies placed on so-called “threshold” lists – which have a high number of borrowed shares that have not been delivered.

Some of the elements could help to guard against abusive short-selling. However, they would fall short of calls by some market participants to extend the provisions of the emergency order to the rest of the market.

Mr Coffee said the “tremendous” short-selling pressure on Lehman, “may have made the difference,” adding: “There could be other companies that get into trouble.”

Lehman, which has been one of the most heavily-shorted stocks, had 18.5 per cent of its stock shares held by short-sellers as of last Thursday, according to the latest available data from Data Explorers. That is almost double the level of the week before, though shy of the record 22 per cent held by short-sellers in July.

The SEC declined to comment but people close to the situation said the regulator may also decide to issue a measure shortening the time brokers have before they must buy a company’s stock to clear a short sale – to five days from the current 13.

More in this section

Amid the turmoil, do not forget the poor

UK launches £37bn bank rescue

Scramble to avoid collapse

MUFG deal boosts Morgan Stanley

Eurozone set to pledge billions in rescue bid

UAE ministry offers further liquidity

Market crash shakes world

G7 ministers agree joint action

US in de facto support for bank liabilities

The week that panic stalked the markets

Q&A: The crisis explained