Last updated: February 13, 2014 7:20 pm

Apple to name-and-shame suppliers of ‘conflict minerals’

A clerk arranges Apple's iPhone 5C phones bearing the logo of China Mobile at a mobile phone shop in Beijing©Reuters

Apple is extending its supply chain clean up beyond Chinese factories and into African mines, using name-and-shame tactics to cut the amount of “conflict minerals” that end up in its iPhones and iPads.

As it touts fresh improvements to working conditions in the factories that produce its devices, the world’s most valuable technology company is now combining its might in electronics-component purchasing and marketing to pressure smelters to make their sourcing more ethical.

Jeff Williams, Apple’s senior vice-president of operations, told the Financial Times that last month was the first time it was able to verify that none of the tantalum used in capacitors and resistors in its devices had come from mines in conflict regions.

It is now urging “conflict-free” audits for gold, tin and tungsten suppliers by publishing a list of all its suppliers’ smelters and their compliance with ethical sourcing guidelines every quarter.

“We think it has the chance to make a difference,” Mr Williams said. “The smelters are a choke point where all this flows through. If we can get as many smelters verified [as possible] through this pressure, then we have a real chance of influencing the nefarious activities on the ground.”

The electronics industry faces growing criticism from human rights organisations and impending regulation from US financial authorities over its extensive use of conflict minerals mined from sites controlled by violent militias in the Democratic Republic of Congo and nearby areas.

Under the new Dodd Frank regulations, certain US companies, including Apple, are required to provide information to the Securities and Exchange Commission about their conflict mineral usage before a May deadline.

“The fastest way for Apple to become conflict-free would be to channel our demand through a couple of verified smelters,” Mr Williams said ahead of the publication of its annual “Supplier Responsibility” report.

“But quite honestly, if we did that, we could wave our conflict-free flag but it would do nothing to affect the workers on the ground. And so what we are focused on is getting a critical mass of suppliers verified such that we can truly influence the demand situation and change things.”

More than half of the world’s tantalum flows through the electronics industry, Mr Williams said, making it easier to exert pressure through its supply chain to cut down the use of mines that are seen as “unacceptable from a human rights standpoint”.

However, for tin, tungsten and gold, Apple and other technology companies are a smaller customer, and so it is using the glare of public scrutiny to encourage change.

The first publication of its quarterly report named 59 smelters that were already compliant, and 23 that were participating in the Conflict-Free Smelter Programme.

This scheme is run by the Electronic Industry Citizenship Coalition, an independent organisation that counts Apple, Microsoft, IBM, HP, Sony and Dell among its fee-paying members. The adherence to ethical guidelines of a further 104 smelters, mainly processing gold and tin, was not known. They include smelters operated by Codelco, the world’s largest copper miner, and Kazzinc, a subsidiary of Glencore Xstrata, as well as Boliden of Sweden and Aurubis of Germany, Apple said.

A report by research group IHS in 2012 found that only 11.3 per cent of electronics component manufacturers provided such data but companies such as Samsung and LG have recently stepped up their efforts to detail sourcing. Last month, Intel said that it was manufacturing the first microprocessors with validated conflict-free gold, tin, tantalum and tungsten.

FT Video Archive

Apple’s new iPhones

September 2013 : Apple has unveiled two new iPhones, including a cheaper model aimed at emerging market countries and a more premium device, successor of the iPhone 5. Paul Taylor, the FT’s personal technology columnist, reports

Elsewhere in its annual Supplier Responsibility report, Apple said that 95 per cent of more than 1m of its suppliers’ workers adhered to a maximum 60-hour work week, up from 92 per cent a year ago.

After the 2012 audit found more than 100 instances of underage labour in 11 of its suppliers’ facilities, Apple last year found 11 active cases and 12 historical cases of children under 15 working in eight facilities.

Mr Williams said that these improvements were accompanied by wider education of health and safety and working conditions among its suppliers.

“We’d like to drive [working hours compliance] up above 95 per cent but the right answer is close to somewhere where we are,” he said. “I don’t think a single week here or there where someone works longer is the end of the world . . . The real win is to go deeper in the supply chain and find more and more places where 70-80 hours a week is the norm and get those pulled in line.”

In a report published in December, the Fair Labor Association, which has worked with Apple in the past to audit its suppliers, found that Foxconn had implemented 356 of its 360 recommendations to improve working conditions at three Chinese factories making Apple products.

The FLA found that “steady progress” in terms of working hours had been made at the facilities, which it estimates employ 170,000 workers, but noted that they were still “not in compliance with Chinese labour law regarding hours of work”.

Carolina Milanesi, a mobile industry analyst with Kantar Worldpanel, said: “We’ve definitely seen an increase in the level of detail and the focus [Apple] put on this sort of thing since Tim [Cook] became chief executive.”

Mr Williams now holds most of Mr Cook’s former duties as chief operating officer, having been promoted in 2010 after 16 years working at Apple.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2015. You may share using our article tools.
Please don't cut articles from and redistribute by email or post to the web.


Sign up for email briefings to stay up to date on topics you are interested in